The short version: a gas furnace with an AC is the familiar setup. A modern heat pump heats and cools with one machine and can cut energy use. HomeAdvisor says a heat pump paired with a gas furnace (dual fuel) is what it recommends for areas that regularly drop below 32°F. A Columbus January averages a 24°F low, so get quotes on at least two setups.
What a Columbus January asks of a system
The average January in Columbus runs a 37°F high and a 24°F low, and the cold season lasts from about December 2 to March 2 (Weather Spark). So the average January night is below freezing, and a heating system here works hard for about three months.
That matters for heat pumps. The U.S. Department of Energy says newer cold-climate air-source heat pumps can heat even in cold regions such as the upper Midwest, and can cut household energy use by up to 40%. It names homes now heated with electric resistance (baseboard) or fuel oil as the ones likely to save the most (DOE). It doesn't make that claim for homes heated with gas, so ask any contractor to show you the numbers for your house.
HomeAdvisor notes that heat pumps work best in temperate climates, that efficiency drops a lot below about 10°F, and that backup heat is then needed (HomeAdvisor).
What each setup costs
Gas furnace plus AC
New furnace: $2,823 to $6,897, average $4,814 (HomeAdvisor). New central AC: $3,887 to $8,073 (HomeAdvisor). Two machines, and the furnace works the cold months.
Heat pump alone
$4,237 to $7,942, average $6,088. Air-source models run $4,500 to $8,000, and ductless mini-splits $1,300 to $8,000 (HomeAdvisor). One machine heats and cools.
Dual fuel, a heat pump plus a gas furnace, runs $2,500 to $10,000 or more (HomeAdvisor). Ductwork, if you have none, is $3,000 to $7,500 on that page. National ranges, not Columbus quotes.
Ducts, refrigerant and the permit
Older houses and ducts
If the house was built before central air, ducts may be tight or missing. A ductless mini-split can skip the ducts, and a contractor can tell you which suits the rooms you have.
The refrigerant in a new system
Since January 1, 2025, most new residential air conditioners and heat pumps must use a refrigerant with a global warming potential of 700 or less. That rules out R-410A in new equipment, and A2L refrigerants such as R-454B and R-32 are now standard (Greenheck). EPA says you can keep using and repairing an existing system that uses the older refrigerant (EPA FAQ).
Permit and license
Columbus requires mechanical inspections for HVAC installations (city mechanical page), and the company must hold the Ohio license for its trade to work in the city (Columbus contractor licenses). Ask who pulls the permit and for the license number.
If the power or the gas goes out
A heat pump runs on electricity and a gas furnace burns gas, so a power outage or a gas problem hits each one differently. Ask the contractor what you would do in either case. AEP Ohio's outage map shows what's down. If you smell gas, leave and call 911 and Columbia Gas at 1-800-344-4077 (Columbia Gas).
Questions for the contractor
- Can you show me the heat the house loses on a 10°F night, not just the size of the old unit?
- What would the monthly bill look like with gas, electric and dual fuel?
- What backup heat does the heat pump use on the coldest days?
- Who pulls the Columbus mechanical permit, and is it in the price?
- Can I see the license number and check it?
Want the money side first? See every price with its source.